Skip to main content

Qualifying Exam

UC San Diego requires a Qualifying Examination for Advancement to Candidacy for the Ph.D. The exam demonstrates that a student has generated sufficient preliminary data to indicate they are on track to complete and successfully defend their thesis within the next two years.

 

We hope your research is going well and that you are excited at the prospect of presenting your preliminary findings and proposed thesis project to your Doctoral Committee. This is the last exam you will take before you defend your thesis. To advance to candidacy, you must complete the following steps, more details can be found in the Qualifying Exam Instructions.

  1.  Email chem-gradadvising@ucsd.edu with your proposed Committee at least 4 weeks before your exam. 

  2. Submit your research summary to your Committee and Student Affairs at least 2 weeks before your exam.
  3. Schedule the exam prior to the end of Spring quarter. Once a date is confirmed, check the rooms calendars and submit a room request.

Students are expected to advance to candidacy by the spring of their third year, although this requirement may be completed earlier if desired. Extensions require prior approval, submit a petition to begin this process if you know you will need additional time. Students who do not advance by the deadline and do not have an approved extension will have a hold placed on their Fall quarter registration.

Doctoral Committee

One of the purposes of a Doctoral Committee is to provide students with mentorship and guidance beyond that provided by the Thesis Advisor. In coordination with the Thesis Advisor, students must constitute their committee. An advancement exam must not be scheduled unless GEPA has approved the student's committee. To ensure the committee is approved on time for the examination, students must submit their committee to Student Affairs at least four weeks prior.

Membership of the doctoral committee must comply with the Manual of the San Diego Division, Academic Senate, Regulation 715. Effective for Fall 2021, committee membership rules have been updated to the following:

  • Minimum of 4 members with UC San Diego faculty appointments
  • At least 1 member must have a primary appointment in a different department than the chair's primary department
  • At least 2 members must be from the student's home department 
  • At least 1 member must be tenured or emeritus

JDP Committee

A Doctoral Committee of five or more members shall be appointed by the Dean of Graduate Studies under the authority of the Graduate Council. At least five of the committee members shall be officers of instruction and no fewer than four shall hold professorial titles (of any rank). The committee members shall be chosen from at least two departments, and at least two members shall represent academic specialties that differ from the student’s chosen specialty. In all cases, each committee must include one tenured or emeritus UCSD faculty member from outside the student’s major department. [Am 10/26/93]

For more information and committee membership table, visit GEPA - Doctoral Committees website.

Subsequent changes to a committee require both Department and GEPA approval. Please contact chem-gradadvising@ucsd.edu for information.

Hybrid Accommodations

All Qualifying exams are required to be conducted in-person. An approved Hybrid exam petition is required if one or more committee members cannot attend in-person or simultaneously. Allow up to 2 weeks to receive a response on your petition.

If approved for a hybrid exam, the Committee Chair will need to setup the Zoom meeting and invite any committee members approved to be remote. Before setting up the Zoom meeting, please take a moment to carefully review these Zoom meeting safeguards to keep your exam safe and secure.

Components of the Examination

The qualifying exam consists of two parts, similar to the Department exam, but uniform across research tracks: a written summary and oral presentation. The oral presentation carries the heavier weight. 
 

  1. Written Summary: Students submit their written summary of their research progress to their Doctoral Committee and Student Affairs, chem-gradadvising@ucsd.edu, at least 2 weeks before the scheduled Qualifying Examination date. The summary should include:
  • A comprehensive description of the proposed thesis research, including key references
  • The significance of the research project(s) 
  • Progress made to date 

 

This summary should be no longer than 3 pages, single-spaced, including figures. Failure to provide this written summary may result in cancellation and/or rescheduling of the exam.

 

  1. Oral Presentation: Students should prepare to give a ~30-40-minute presentation that includes:
  • A brief overview of the context, significance, and potential impact of their thesis project(s)
  • Preliminary data 

 

By the exam date, students are expected to have demonstrated their ability to design, carryout, and analyze data they have generated. The presentation should clearly present the data, with motivation and background understandable to a non-expert audience, aims should be highlighted, proposed research has elements of background and personal effort, conclusion highlights unique contributions from the student, and references should be complete. Figures and data should be included. 

Potential Outcomes

Pass - the exam has demonstrated that sufficient preliminary data has been generated to suggest a student is on track to complete and successfully defend their thesis within the next 2 years as well as a command of the theoretical/experimental basis of their thesis work. After receiving a Pass outcome, a student can apply to advance to candidacy for the doctoral degree.

Provisional Pass - the exam has identified weaknesses to be addressed by the student to meet the status of a Pass. A provisional pass outcome is accompanied with a proscribed remediation plan as outlined by the committee and communicated verbally and in writing to the student. This plan will include timelines for completion and methods for evaluation. Re-examination outcomes are limited to pass or fail.

Fail - the exam has demonstrated that a student has not satisfactorily made research progress towards completing their Ph.D. thesis in a reasonable timeline and/or that critical theoretical and/or experimental understandings remain deficient. This outcome is accompanied with 1 of 3 recommendations: Re-examination, Terminal Masters, or Termination. In cases of Fail with recommendation of re-examination, the committee provides a proscribed remediation plan as outlined by the committee and communicated verbally and in writing to the student. This plan will include timelines for completion and methods for evaluation. Re-examination outcomes are limited to pass or fail.  

After the Exam

Once a student has successfully passed the Qualifying Examination, the committee will sign the Advancement to Candidacy form. Student Affairs will coordinate securing the required departmental signatures via DocuSign. The student will receive a copy of the completed form once it is delivered to GEPA for processing.

JDP Students

The SDSU JDP Coordinator will initiate and route the Advancement to Candidacy (JDP-3) form to all required signees via Adobe Sign. The signature routing order will be: Doctoral Committee > SDSU/UCSD Co-Directors >  Student > SDSU Graduate Affairs > UCSD Graduate Division > Final copy sent to everyone. Because signatures are required from both campuses, be certain to allow reasonable time to obtain all the required signatures.

The Advancement to Candidacy form must be signed by all Committee members no later than Friday of Finals Week to be processed by GEPA. Late submissions will be processed the following quarter.